Filter By

Insurance

Insurance

• Aetna (626)
• Cigna (579)
• Blue Cross Blue Shield (578)
• MVP Health Care (491)
• UnitedHealthCare (483)

• Oxford Health Plans (437)
• Empire Blue Cross Blue Shield (422)
• Excellus BlueCross BlueShield (386)
• MagnaCare (384)
• Highmark Blue Cross Blue Shield (370)
• First Health (349)
• CareFirst BlueCross BlueShield (300)
• Fidelis Care (257)
• Curative (233)
• Oscar Health (176)
• Humana (168)
• EmblemHealth (160)
• Anthem (140)
• CareFirst Blue Cross Blue Shield (123)
• Healthfirst (112)
• Liberty Mutual Insurance Company (109)
• Connecticare (102)
• Amerihealth (101)
• Capital District Physician's Health Plan (CDPHP) (94)
• Highmark Blue Cross Blue Shield of Western New York (94)
• MultiPlan (91)
• Harvard Pilgrim Health Care (57)
• Medicare (48)
• Independence Blue Cross (34)
• Medicaid (34)
• Anthem Blue Cross (1)
• Anthem Blue Cross Blue Shield (1)
• Anthem Blue Cross Life and Health Insurance Company (1)
• Blue Care Network of Michigan (1)
• Blue Care Network of Michigan (BCN) (1)
• Blue Cross & Blue Shield of Rhode Island (1)
• Blue Cross & Blue Shield of South Carolina (1)
• Blue Cross and Blue Shield of Alabama (1)
• Blue Cross and Blue Shield of Florida, Inc. d/b/a Florida Blue (1)
• Blue Cross and Blue Shield of Illinois (1)
• Blue Cross and Blue Shield of Kansas (1)
• Blue Cross and Blue Shield of Louisiana (1)
• Blue Cross and Blue Shield of Massachusetts (1)
• Blue Cross and Blue Shield of Minnesota (1)
• Blue Cross and Blue Shield of Nebraska (1)
• Blue Cross and Blue Shield of New Mexico (1)
• Blue Cross and Blue Shield of North Carolina (1)
• Blue Cross and Blue Shield of Oklahoma (1)
• Blue Cross and Blue Shield of South Carolina (1)
• Blue Cross and Blue Shield of Texas (1)
• Blue Cross Blue Shield of Arizona (1)
• Blue Cross Blue Shield of Arkansas (1)
• Blue Cross Blue Shield of California (1)
• Blue Cross Blue Shield of Delaware (1)
• Blue Cross Blue Shield of Florida (1)
• Blue Cross Blue Shield of Georgia (1)
• Blue Cross Blue Shield of Indiana (1)
• Blue Cross Blue Shield of Kansas City (1)
• Blue Cross Blue Shield of Michigan (1)
• Blue Cross Blue Shield of Mississippi (1)
• Blue Cross Blue Shield of Missouri (1)
• Blue Cross Blue Shield of North Dakota (1)
• Blue Cross Blue Shield of Pennsylvania (1)
• Blue Cross Blue Shield of Western New York (1)
• Blue Cross Blue Shield of Wisconsin (1)
• Blue Cross Blue Shield of Wyoming (1)
• Blue Cross of Idaho (1)
• Blue Medicare Advantage (1)
• Blue Shield of California (1)
• Blue Shield of Northeastern New York (1)
• BlueAdvantage Administrators of Arkansas (1)
• BlueCross BlueShield of Tennessee (1)
• Canopy Health (1)
• Capital Blue Cross (1)
• CareFirst BlueChoice, Inc. (1)
• CBA Blue (1)
• ChoiceCare Network (1)
• Cigna-HealthSpring (1)
• Delta Dental (1)
• Delta Dental of Minnesota (1)
• Delta Dental of New York (1)
• Delta Dental of Washington (1)
• Florida Blue (1)
• Health Net (1)
• Highmark Blue Cross Blue Shield West Virginia (1)
• Highmark Blue Shield of Northeastern New York (1)
• Horizon Blue Cross Blue Shield of New Jersey (1)
• Humana Benefit Plan of Illinois (1)
• Humana Employers Health Plan of Georgia (1)
• Humana Health Benefit Plan of Louisiana (1)
• Humana Health Plan of Ohio (1)
• Humana Health Plan of Texas (1)
• Humana Veterans (1)
• Humana/CompBenefits (1)
• HumanaOne (1)
• Kaiser Foundation Health Plan of Colorado (1)
• Kaiser Foundation Health Plan of Georgia, Inc. (1)
• Kaiser Foundation Health Plan of the Mid-Atlantic States, Inc. (1)
• Kaiser Foundation Health Plan of the Northwest (1)
• Kaiser Foundation Health Plan, Inc. (1)
• Kaiser Permanente (1)
• Kaiser Permanente of the Mid-Atlantic States (1)
• Medicaid of Alabama (1)
• Medicaid of Alaska (1)
• Medicaid of Arizona (1)
• Medicaid of Arkansas (1)
• Medicaid of California (1)
• Medicaid of Colorado (1)
• Medicaid of Connecticut (1)
• Medicaid of Delaware (1)
• Medicaid of Florida (1)
• Medicaid of Georgia (1)
• Medicaid of Hawaii (1)
• Medicaid of Idaho (1)
• Medicaid of Illinois (1)
• Medicaid of Indiana (1)
• Medicaid of Iowa (1)
• Medicaid of Kansas (1)
• Medicaid of Kentucky (1)
• Medicaid of Louisiana (1)
• Medicaid of Maine (1)
• Medicaid of Maryland (1)
• Medicaid of Massachusetts (1)
• Medicaid of Michigan (1)
• Medicaid of Minnesota (1)
• Medicaid of Mississippi (1)
• Medicaid of Missouri (1)
• Medicaid of Montana (1)
• Medicaid of Nebraska (1)
• Medicaid of Nevada (1)
• Medicaid of New Hampshire (1)
• Medicaid of New Jersey (1)
• Medicaid of New York (1)
• Medicaid of North Carolina (1)
• Medicaid of North Dakota (1)
• Medicaid of Ohio (1)
• Medicaid of Oklahoma (1)
• Medicaid of Oregon (1)
• Medicaid of Pennsylvania (1)
• Medicaid of Rhode Island (1)
• Medicaid of South Carolina (1)
• Medicaid of South Dakota (1)
• Medicaid of Tennessee (1)
• Medicaid of Texas (1)
• Medicaid of Utah (1)
• Medicaid of Vermont (1)
• Medicaid of Virginia (1)
• Medicaid of Washington State (1)
• Medicaid of West Virginia (1)
• Medicaid of Wisconsin (1)
• Medicaid of Wyoming (1)
• Medicare of Oklahoma (1)
• Medicare of Texas (1)
• Premera Blue Cross (1)
• Regence Blue Cross Blue Shield (1)
• Regence Blue Cross Blue Shield of Utah (1)
• Regence Blue Shield of Washington (1)
• Regence BlueCross BlueShield of Oregon (1)
• Regence BlueShield (1)
• Trigon Blue Cross Blue Shield (1)
• Truli for Health (1)
• United Concordia (1)
• United Concordia Dental (1)
• UnitedHealth Group (1)
• UnitedHealthcare Benefits of Texas (1)
• UnitedHealthcare of California (1)
• UnitedHealthcare Plan of the River Valley (1)
• UnitedHealthOne (1)
• Wellmark Blue Cross and Blue Shield (1)

View All

Gender

Gender

• Female (405)
• Male (360)

Distance

Distance

• 1 mile (82)
• 5 miles (765)
• 10 miles (2446)
• 25 miles (4504)
• 50 miles (5967)
• 100 miles (8855)
• National (70047)

Specialty

Specialty

• Obstetrics & Gynecology (492)
• Gynecology (70)
• Orthopedic Surgery (66)
• Pain Medicine (54)
• Physical Medicine & Rehabilitation (37)

• Pain Management (20)
• Obstetrics (19)
• Gynecologic Surgery (13)
• Sports Medicine (12)
• Urogynecology & Reconstructive Pelvic Surgery (12)
• Family Medicine (11)
• Anesthesiology (10)
• Orthopedics (9)
• Maternal-Fetal Medicine (9)
• Family Planning (8)
• Reproductive Endocrinology & Infertility (8)
• Gynecologic Oncology (8)
• Internal Medicine (7)
• Orthopedic Spine Surgery (7)
• Pain Medicine Anesthesiology (7)
• Hip & Knee Orthopedics (7)
• Interventional Pain Medicine (6)
• Hospital Medicine (5)
• Pediatric Gynecology (4)
• Female Pelvic Medicine & Reconstructive Surgery (4)
• Reconstructive Orthopedic Surgery (4)
• Interventional Spine Medicine (3)
• Integrative Medicine (3)
• Pediatric Non-Surgical Orthopedics (3)
• Women's Health Medicine (3)

View All

Age

Age

• Under 40 (128)
• 41-50 (189)
• 51-60 (170)
• 61-70 (124)
• Over 70 (103)

Availability

Availability

• Today (75)
• Tomorrow (77)
• Within 2 weeks (125)
• Schedules online (74)
• Accepts new patients (546)
• Telehealth (386)

Language

Language

• American Sign Language (1)
• Amharic (1)
• Arabic (25)
• Azerbaijani (1)
• Bangla (1)

• Bengali (5)
• Bosnian (1)
• Burmese (1)
• Cantonese (2)
• Chinese (44)
• Chinese, Cantonese (18)
• Chinese, Mandarin (17)
• Creole (5)
• Croatian (1)
• Dutch (2)
• Farsi (6)
• French (44)
• French Creole (3)
• Georgian (1)
• German (5)
• Greek (8)
• Gujarati (5)
• Haitian Creole (2)
• Hausa (1)
• Hebrew (33)
• Hindi (23)
• Hungarian (1)
• Igbo (1)
• Italian (12)
• Kannada (1)
• Korean (9)
• Latin (1)
• Malayalam (1)
• Mandarin (5)
• Marathi (3)
• Panjabi (1)
• Pashto (1)
• Polish (9)
• Portuguese (5)
• Punjabi (6)
• Romanian (2)
• Russian (67)
• Serbian (1)
• Spanish (158)
• Swedish (1)
• Tagalog (4)
• Taiwanese (1)
• Tamil (1)
• Telugu (3)
• Turkish (2)
• Ukrainian (10)
• Urdu (12)
• Vietnamese (1)
• Yiddish (3)
• Yoruba (1)

View All

Patient Satisfaction

Patient Satisfaction

• 5 Stars (138)
• 4 Stars And Higher (335)
• 3 Stars And Higher (487)
• 2 Stars And Higher (562)
• 1 Star And Higher (598)

Affiliated Facility

Affiliated Facility

• NYU Langone Hospitals (190)
• Maimonides Medical Center (107)
• New York-Presbyterian Hospital (106)
• Newyork-Presbyterian Brooklyn Methodist Hospital (98)
• Staten Island University Hospital (92)

• NYU Langone Hospital-Brooklyn (71)
• The Brooklyn Hospital Center (58)
• North Shore University Hospital (55)
• Lenox Hill Hospital (51)
• Mount Sinai Hospital (42)
• Long Island Jewish Medical Center (38)
• Wyckoff Heights Medical Center (36)
• NYC Health + Hospitals/Kings County (32)
• NewYork-Presbyterian Queens (32)
• Brookdale Hospital Medical Center (30)
• Newyork-Presbyterian Lower Manhattan Hospital (28)
• University Hospital at Downstate (28)
• Mount Sinai Morningside (25)
• Hospital for Special Surgery (25)
• NYC Health + Hospitals/Woodhull (22)
• Mount Sinai West (20)
• Jamaica Hospital Medical Center (18)
• Flushing Hospital Medical Center (17)
• Saint John's Episcopal Hospital at South Shore (15)
• NYC Health + Hospitals/Bellevue (13)
• Mercy Medical Center (12)
• Plainview Hospital (12)
• Maimonides Midwood Community Hospital (11)
• St John's Riverside Hospital (10)
• Montefiore Medical Center (9)
• Richmond University Medical Center (9)
• White Plains Hospital (9)
• NYU Langone Hospital-Long Island (9)
• Hackensack University Medical Center (8)
• Newyork-Presbyterian/Columbia University Medical Center (8)
• Mount Sinai South Nassau (8)
• NYC Health + Hospitals/South Brooklyn Health (8)
• Nassau University Medical Center (7)
• Phelps Hospital (7)
• St Charles Hospital (7)
• NYC Health + Hospitals/Lincoln (7)
• Stamford Hospital (7)
• Mount Sinai Brooklyn (7)
• Stony Brook University Hospital (7)
• Glen Cove Hospital (7)
• NYC Health + Hospitals/Jacobi (7)
• Holy Name Medical Center (6)
• New York-Presbyterian Hospital/Lawrence (6)
• NYC Health + Hospitals/Harlem (6)
• NYC Health + Hospitals/Elmhurst (6)
• Saint Joseph's Medical Center (5)
• Westchester Medical Center (5)
• Yale New Haven Hospital (4)
• Hudson Regional Hospital (4)
• St. Joseph's University Medical Center (4)
• Northern Westchester Hospital (4)
• Monmouth Medical Center (4)
• NYC Health + Hospitals/Metropolitan (4)
• Garnet Health Medical Center-Catskills, Harris Campus (4)
• Englewood Hospital (4)
• Atlantic Health Morristown Medical Center (4)
• Atlantic Health Overlook Medical Center (4)
• Peconic Bay Medical Center (4)
• Newyork-Presbyterian (4)
• St. Joseph's Health Hospital (3)
• Greenwich Hospital (3)
• Northern Dutchess Hospital (3)
• The Valley Hospital (3)
• Grady Memorial Hospital (3)
• Samaritan Hospital (3)
• South Shore University Hospital (3)
• Newyork-Presbyterian Hudson Valley Hospital (3)
• Lehigh Valley Hospital Pocono (3)
• BronxCare Hospital Center (3)
• JFK University Medical Center (3)
• Montefiore Mount Vernon Hospital (3)
• Interfaith Medical Center (3)
• Long Island Community Hospital (3)
• Atlantic Health Chilton Medical Center (3)
• Saint Peter's University Hospital (3)
• Good Samaritan Hospital (3)
• Crouse Hospital (3)
• Hackensack Meridian Mountainside Medical Center (2)
• Montefiore Nyack Hospital (2)
• Stony Brook Eastern Long Island Hospital (2)
• Emory University Hospital Midtown (2)
• University Medical Center New Orleans (2)
• Emory University Hospital (2)
• Baystate Medical Center (2)
• Newton-Wellesley Hospital (2)
• Norwalk Hospital (2)
• Rapides Regional Medical Center (2)
• Raritan Bay Medical Center (2)
• Atlantic Health CentraState Medical Center (2)
• Ocean University Medical Center (2)
• Garnet Health Medical Center (2)
• Port Jervis Community Hospital (2)
• Piedmont Mountainside (2)
• NYC Health + Hospitals/Queens (2)
• MUSC Medical Center (2)
• Piedmont Fayette Hospital (2)
• Robert Wood Johnson University Hospital Somerset (2)
• Community Medical Center (2)
• Mount Sinai Queens (2)
• Cleveland Clinic Indian River Hospital (2)
• NewYork-Presbyterian/The Allen Hospital (2)
• Oneida Health (2)
• Piedmont Hospital (2)
• Penn Medicine Princeton Medical Center (2)
• St. Francis Hospital & Heart Center (2)
• Piedmont Athens Regional Medical Center (2)
• Palisades Medical Center (2)
• UCHealth University of Colorado Hospital (1)
• Bridgeport Hospital (1)
• Jersey Shore University Medical Center (1)
• The Medical Center at Bowling Green (1)
• Baptist Memorial Hospital-Memphis (1)
• Stony Brook Southampton Hospital (1)
• Grace Cottage Hospital (1)
• Zuckerberg San Francisco General Hospital and Trauma Center (1)
• St. David's South Austin Medical Center (1)
• Memorial Regional Hospital (1)
• Sparrow Hospital (1)
• UChicago Medicine AdventHealth Bolingbrook (1)
• Lehigh Valley Hospital (1)
• Inspira Medical Center Vineland (1)
• Rome Health Hospital (1)
• TriStar Hendersonville Medical Center (1)
• Lake Charles Memorial Hospital (1)
• Oswego Hospital (1)
• Inova Alexandria Hospital (1)
• Providence Little Company of Mary Medical Center Torrance (1)
• Cape Cod Hospital (1)
• University Hospital S University N Y Health Science Center (1)
• Rush Copley Medical Center (1)
• MultiCare Good Samaritan Hospital (1)
• Waterbury Hospital (1)
• Piedmont Newton Hospital (1)
• St. David's Medical Center (1)
• Emory Saint Joseph's Hospital (1)
• Long Island Jewish Valley Stream (1)
• Arnot Ogden Medical Center (1)
• Marinhealth Medical Center (1)
• Montefiore St. Luke's Cornwall (1)
• Doctors Hospital (1)
• Cooper University Hospital Cape Regional (1)
• Thomas Jefferson University Hospital (1)
• Skagit Valley Hospital (1)
• Albany Medical Center Hospital (1)
• Berkshire Medical Center (1)
• MUSC Health Florence Medical Center (1)
• Inova Loudoun Hospital (1)
• NYC Health + Hospitals/North Central Bronx (1)
• Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center (1)
• Ochsner Lafayette General Medical Center (1)
• St. Mary's Medical Center (1)
• Beth Israel Deaconess Hospital-Milton (1)
• Ascension Sacred Heart Pensacola (1)
• University of Cincinnati Medical Center (1)
• Helen Hayes Hospital (1)
• South Florida Baptist Hospital (1)
• The University of Chicago Medical Center (1)
• Mather Hospital (1)
• Select Specialty Hospital-Philadelph (1)
• Mount Sinai Medical Center (1)
• Tulane Medical Center (1)
• Garfield Medical Center (1)
• McLeod Regional Medical Center (1)
• Emory Hillandale Hospital (1)
• St. Anthony Community Hospital (1)
• Rockledge Regional Medical Center (1)
• TriStar Northcrest Medical Center (1)
• UHS Binghamton General Hospital (1)
• CHRISTUS Southeast Texas-Saint Elizabeth (1)
• Hartford Hospital (1)
• Higgins General Hospital (1)
• University of North Carolina Hospital (1)
• Jersey City Medical Center (1)
• Cleveland Clinic (1)
• Penn Highlands Brookville (1)
• Nicklaus Children's Hospital (1)
• Newark-Wayne Community Hospital (1)
• Southwest Memorial Hospital (1)
• Whidbeyhealth Medical Center (1)
• Columbia Memorial Hospital (1)
• Emory Decatur Hospital (1)
• Weiss Memorial Hospital (1)
• MUSC Health Marion Medical Center (1)
• Kadlec Regional Medical Center (1)
• Texas Health Presbyterian Hospital Dallas (1)
• Robert Wood Johnson University Hospital at Rahway (1)
• Kaiser Permanente Redwood City Medical Center (1)
• Parkview Regional Hospital (1)
• Bergen New Bridge Medical Center (1)
• Kaiser Foundation Hospital West La (1)
• St Mary's Hospital (1)
• Newyork-Presbyterian/Morgan Stanley Children's Hospital (1)
• Inova Fairfax Hospital (1)
• Penn Highlands Elk (1)
• MUSC Health Kershaw Medical Center (1)
• Kaiser Permanente Roseville Medical Center (1)
• BronxCare Health System— Fulton Campus (1)
• The University of Vermont Health Network-Alice HY (1)
• Orlando Health South Lake Hospital (1)
• Providence St. Peter Hospital (1)
• MedStar Harbor Hospital (1)
• Boston Medical Center (1)
• Blessing Hospital (1)
• Danbury Hospital (1)
• Our Lady of Lourdes Memorial Hospital (1)
• Platte Valley Hospital (1)
• Wentworth-Douglass Hospital (1)
• Wilkes-Barre General Hospital (1)
• MedStar Franklin Square Medical Center (1)
• Mercy Hospital of Buffalo (1)
• Memorial Hospital Belleville (1)
• Evergreenhealth Medical Center-Kirkland (1)
• Broward Health Medical Center (1)
• Baylor Scott and White Medical Center-Waxahachie (1)
• Wellstar Kennestone Regional Medical Center (1)
• North Adams Regional Hospital (1)
• HCA Houston Healthcare Clear Lake (1)
• Heber Valley Hospital (1)
• Piedmont Walton Hospital (1)
• Atlantic Health Newton Medical Center (1)
• HCA Florida Lawnwood Hospital (1)
• Sumner Regional Medical Center (1)
• Lakeland Regional Medical Center (1)
• Montrose Regional Health (1)
• Newark Beth Israel Medical Center (1)
• HCA Florida Brandon Hospital (1)
• Lutheran Hospital (1)
• Houston Methodist Willowbrook Hospital (1)
• CHRISTUS Saint Frances Cabrini Hospital (1)
• Kaiser Permanente Santa Clara Medical Center (1)
• Bethesda Hospital East (1)
• Fairview Hospital (1)
• DMC Sinai-Grace Hospital (1)
• St. David's North Austin Medical Center (1)
• Sentara Norfolk General Hospital (1)
• Adirondack Medical Center Saranac Lake (1)
• Providence St. Joseph Hospital Orange (1)
• Ascension Sacred Heart Bay (1)
• Memorial Hospital Miramar (1)
• DCH Regional Medical Center (1)
• Kenmore Mercy Hospital (1)
• West Boca Medical Center (1)
• Stanford Hospital (1)
• SSM Health DePaul Hospital-St. Louis (1)
• CHRISTUS Ochsner Lake Area Hospital (1)
• AdventHealth Orlando (1)
• Alton Memorial Hospital (1)
• Rochester General Hospital (1)
• Northside Hospital (1)
• Bayhealth Hospital, Sussex (1)
• UCSF Helen Diller Medical Center at Parnassus Heights (1)
• Palestine Regional Medical Center (1)
• Huntington Hospital (1)
• Jefferson Abington Hospital (1)
• Beth Israel Deaconess Hospital Plymouth (1)
• Limestone Medical Center (1)
• UMass Memorial Medical Center-Memorial Campus (1)
• St Peter's Hospital (1)
• Bristol Regional Medical Center (1)
• Memorial Sloan Kettering Cancer Center (1)
• Comanche County Memorial Hospital (1)
• Tristar Summit Medical Center (1)
• University of California Irvine Medical Center (1)
• UC Health West Chester Hospital (1)
• Methodist Hospital (1)
• St Joseph Hospital (1)
• Backus Hospital (1)
• Sentara Princess Anne Hospital (1)
• Vaughan Regional Medical Center (1)
• MUSC Health Columbia Medical Center Downtown (1)
• Long Island Jewish Forest Hills (1)
• Riverview Medical Center (1)
• Ventura County Medical Center (1)
• HCA Florida Mercy Hospital (1)
• San Gabriel Valley Medical Center (1)
• Jefferson Stratford Hospital (1)
• Main Campus Medical Center (1)
• Baylor Scott & White Medical Center-Temple (1)
• Providence Little Company of Mary Medical Center San Pedro (1)
• Saratoga Hospital (1)
• St. Catherine of Siena Hospital (1)
• Stonesprings Hospital Center (1)
• City of Hope Helford Clinical Research Hospital (1)
• Baptist Hospital of Miami (1)
• Henry County Medical Center (1)
• Piedmont Henry Hospital (1)
• Resolute Health Hospital (1)
• Kaiser Permanente South Bay Medical Center (1)
• Sentara Leigh Hospital (1)
• Beth Israel Deaconess Hospital-Needham (1)
• Novant Health Matthews Medical Center (1)
• South Miami Hospital (1)
• Kaiser Permanente Fontana Medical Center (1)
• Delta County Memorial Hospital (1)
• Sebastian River Medical Center (1)
• Good Samaritan Hospital Medical Center (1)
• Monmouth Medical Center Southern Campus (1)
• Wellstar Atlanta Medical Center (1)
• Inspira Medical Center Elmer (1)
• Inspira Medical Center Mullica Hill (1)
• Buffalo General Medical Center (1)
• Kaiser Permanente San Jose Medical Center (1)
• Holy Cross Hospital (1)
• Methodist Richardson Medical Center (1)
• Ascension Providence Hospital (1)
• Glens Falls Hospital (1)
• Brigham and Women's Faulkner Hospital (1)
• Virginia Hospital Center (1)
• Inova Fair Oaks Hospital (1)
• Northwestern Memorial Hospital (1)
• Bon Secours St. Francis Hospital (1)
• MidHudson Regional Hospital (1)
• Piedmont Newnan (1)
• Montefiore New Rochelle Hospital (1)
• Baylor Scott & White Medical Center-Hillcrest (1)
• Vassar Brothers Medical Center (1)
• Christiana Hospital (1)
• St. Luke's Health-Memorial Hospital-Lufkin, TX (1)

View All

Affirming Care

Affirming Care

• LGBTQ+ affirming (2)